ETF Spotlight Newsletter by AltaVista Research

altavista

Chart of the week

Confidence levels, Sector SPDRs

All of the valuation metrics we report to readers are based on what is known as consensus estimates for things like sales and earnings. Consensus numbers are simply the average of figures contributed by all analysts who follow a particular stock. But what if the consensus is wrong? (Imagine that.)

To get an idea of how certain analysts are in their projections, we examined the standard deviation in estimates for 2010-11 EPS to see how wide the range of forecasts for stocks in each of the nine Sector SPDRs. We then subtracted this number from 100% to create a "confidence level," on the basis that if there were no disagreement among analysts (i.e., all EPS estimates were the same) we would have high confidence that the valuation metrics we calculate using these forecasts were accurate.

As you might expect, there is low confidence in estimates for the unpredictable Energy (XLE) and Financial (XLF) sectors, and high confidence in estimates for Health Care (XLV) and Consumer Staples (XLP). However, there is surprisingly high levels of confidence for the Basic Materials (XLB) and Industrials (XLI) sectors. The latter is showing the strongest estimate revisions among all Sector SPDRs, and is the subject of this week's Fund Focus.

Download the full newsletter here

Chart: Confidence levels, Sector SPDRs
100% minus std. dev. in 2010-11 EPS estimates
confidence_levels

Fund Focus

Industrials Select Sector SPDR (XLI)industrials

Sales may pick up modestly this year and next after a devastating double-digit decline in 2009, and with capacity utilization starting to recover margins could improve as well. Expectations have improved markedly in recent months. Still, return on equity is likely to recover only gradually, and in any case valuations appear to already reflect an eventual recovery, resulting in a roughly average ALTAR ScoreTM and risk/reward profile for this cyclical sector.

To download the full newsletter, click here

As always your questions & feedback are most welcome.
 
Sincerely,
 

Michael Krause
AltaVista Research

 

 

     

Australian Securities Exchange - ASX   AUSTRALIAN INVESTORS ASSOCIATION   Kinetic Securities  Terrapinn